Ground breaking work with fellowship money

Bedford Research Foundation supports ground breaking work with fellowship money

As the result of a generous benefactor, the Bedford Research Foundation has placed a fellow in Spain who is contributing significantly to understanding cellular programming and pluripotency in Stem Cells.

Dr. Sebastian Canovas is a Principal Investigator researcher from the Program for Cell Therapy and Regenerative Medicine of Andalucia, Foundation “Progreso y Salud”, in Seville, Spain. Dr Canovas received his DVM in 2002 from the University of Murcia (Spain) and in 2005 he completed his Master’s degree in Biotechnology of Reproduction in Mammals. During six years (2002-2008) he was working in the group Physiology of Reproduction in embryology, sperm functionality and sperm-oocyte interactions.

Following completion of his PhD, he joined Dr. Cibelli’s laboratory (Cellular Reprogramming Laboratory) at Michigan State University (USA) where his research had been focused on understanding the mechanisms of cellular reprogramming during embryo development and induced pluripotent stem cells production. To elucidate these mechanisms, Sebastian studied the role of a H3K27me3 histome demethylase (JMJD3) in bovine at early embryo development and during human make induced pluripotent stem cells process. Also, he has development a project for enhancing the efficiency in the production of safe iPS cells using episomal plasmids and adult somatic cells.

Now, his team is involved on a project to make transdifferentiation from human somatic cells forwards germinal cells. As a result of his work, he has published more than 12 scientific papers in journals with impact factor and he is collaborating in 6 research grants. Dr. Canovas hopes these studies will help lead to cures of rare disorders and fertility, which are affecting the population but they have not an effective treatment.

2014 Annual Appeal for Support

Dear Supporter,

In 1996, the Bedford Research Foundation was formed in response to a need for specialized tests and services that were not available anywhere in the world. Today, we still provide these specialized tests and it has led us to a new model of funding:

“The Foundation is a forward thinking institution that covers overhead costs with fee-for-service testing, thus allowing philanthropic donations to go directly to research.”

– Alan Geismer, Chairman, Board of Trustees
Read More
Illustration of mouse and firefly gene making a glowing mouse

Fall & Winter 2014 Stem Cell Research Update

Bedford Research Stem Cells Glow!

Breakthroughs in understanding circadian rhythms in stem cells.

Fall 2014: Bedford Research scientists are following up on their discovery that stem cells have a circadian rhythm that may need to be supported for optimum development in the laboratory.

In the body, the daily pattern of light and dark controls many signals sent out by the brain, such as those that trigger changes in body temperature, and feelings of hunger and sleepiness.

Stem cells may especially need circadian signals to differentiate into specific cell types, such as neurons or bone marrow — but what type of signal should they receive in the laboratory? And what frequency? There is growing evidence that each type of cell needs a different circadian signal.

Read More

Stem Cell Research – Science Update

Following up Bedford’s discovery that stem cells may be controlled by circadian rhythms.

Bedford Research scientists discovered that stem cells may need circadian rhythm signals. This insight would make them analogous to several types of cells in the body, including some cancer cells. If true, new methods of cell culture need to be developed to enhance stem cell development. Bedford Research scientists isolated a new line of stem cells from a research mouse (Per2Luc) whose cells glow when one of the circadian genes is active (Figure 1). Efforts to study the new Per2Luc stem cells have been hindered by the lack of a sensitive photo-microscope to detect and record the glow — until very recently.  An exciting, new photo-microscope (LV200) is sensitive enough to capture circadian oscillations in the Per2Luc cells (Figure 1). This advance will allow more rapid studies of the importance of circadian signals to stem cell expansion and differentiation.

Read More

Dr. Kiessling gives 2014 commencement to 25,000 at Oregon State University

Update June 15, 2014: Commencement Address a Success
Despite a prank from University of Oregon, Dr. Kiessling’s message about taking an active role in government hit home with the largest graduating class in OSU history. read more…

Update June 18, 2014: Pilot of the “Go Ducks” Plane to Donate $500 to Bedford Research
“We knew that the “Go Ducks !” message would be controversial, but we never imagined the depth of the offense our error in judgment has caused.” read more…

Read More

Bedford Research Foundation 2014 Newsletter

Read about all of the progress and the research that has occurred at the Foundation over the course of the past year, and a retrospective on the past 18! Dr. Kiessling outlines her vision for the upcoming year as well. Thank you for your support.


Bedford Research Foundation is EIGHTEEN

Founded in 1996 to conduct research that cannot be funded by the National Institutes of Health, Bedford Research scientists have achieved ground-breaking milestones!

See our Timeline of Milestones!

 

 Bedford Research Foundation’s work cannot be federally funded because of the Dickey-Wicker Amendment to the budget of the National Institutes of Health, put in place in 1996 and renewed annually. BRF scientists need private donations for research to develop “universal” stem cells for Everybody.
Donate Today!

Bedford Research Stem Cells Glow!

It Works: Breakthroughs in understanding circadian rhythms in stem cells.

Fall 2014: Bedford Research scientists are following up on their discovery that stem cells have a circadian rhythm and that it may need to be supported for optimum development in the laboratory. Illustration of mouse and firefly gene making a glowing mouse In the body, all cells are influenced by the daily pattern of light and dark which controls many signals sent out by the brain, such as those that trigger changes in body temperature, and feelings of hunger and sleepiness.

Stem cells may especially need circadian signals to form into different cell types, such as neurons or bone marrow — but what type of signal should they receive in the laboratory? And what frequency? There is growing evidence that each type of cell needs a different circadian signal.

To answer this question, Bedford Research scientists have taken advantage of a genetically engineered mouse that has the firefly “glow” gene (Luciferase) attached to one of the circadian rhythm genes (the “Period 2” gene). Tissues in this PerLuc mouse “glow” when Period 2 is active.

Recently, Bedford Research scientists derived two new lines of stem cells from the PerLuc mouse, but discovered their circadian signal needs had been hindered by lack of a microscope sensitive enough to detect and photograph the glow of a small number of cells.

The good news is that such a microscope has been developed, and this year became available in the U.S. The bad news is that the system costs $160,000 and is not yet available anywhere on the east coast.

Olympus loaned Bedford Research scientists a demonstration LV200 for a couple of weeks this fall during which we discovered that our PerLuc stem cells do, indeed “glow” (Figure 1), and that the “glow” actually begins soon after activation, and increases as it transitions into stem cells. The “glow” seems to increase as it transitions into stem cells (Figure2).

These exciting new findings provide strong support for the importance of circadian rhythms in stem cell growth and development. One of our goals is to raise funds to purchase the new microscope system as soon as possible in order to discover what circadian signals stimulate differentiation of each cell type

Bedford’s Science Advisory Committee Grows

Dr. Jose Cibelli joins as chair and welcomes four new members. In January of 2014, Bedford Trustee, Dr. Jose Cibelli, Michigan State University, joined Bedford’s Science Advisory Committee as its chair. This summer, the Committee welcomed new members: Dr. Fred Davis, Northeastern University, Dr. David DiGiusto, City of Hope Cancer Research Center, Dr. Phil Horner, University of Washington, and Dr. Steve Sheridan, Harvard Medical School. We’re thrilled to have this amazing committee who join founding member, Dr. Carol Warner, Emeritus, Northeastern University.

Progress in Stem Cell Engineering

There is strong evidence that “off-the shelf” stem cell therapies, i.e. one that can be delivered to any patient, will be possible in the future. In order to create such therapies, we will need stem cells that have been engineered for specific regenerative medicine treatments, such as bone marrow stem cells that are resistant to HIV.

Using “activated” mouse eggs (called “parthenotes”) as a model system, Bedford Research scientists have made substantial progress adapting new technologies to “knock-out” the receptor for HIV. The same technology is being applied to new cell lines for studies of nerve development.

We’re Moving!

After 16 years at Davis Square in Somerville, MA, we are moving to a larger space in Bedford, MA. The need to develop an FDA-approved laboratory module for “bench to bedside” stem cell research, plus a unique “lease to purchase” opportunity prompted the move. We have two years to raise $800,000 to purchase the building. We are seeking support from state life science research funds as well as philanthropists.

We have one pledge of $75,000. To find out more about endowing the laboratory please email ryan@bedfordresearch.org so we can take advantage of the lease opportunity and the savings in overhead that can be diverted to the research.

Prostate Disease

Research Update Patient recruitment into the prostate cancer screening project is ongoing. The goal of the project is to develop semen screening tests that will help diagnose and stage prostate cancer as well as reflect overall male health. A group of urologists in Texas have recently joined the research project and will help recruit patients for the next phase of the work.

OSU Commencement

In June, Dr. Kiessling was honored to give the commencement address at Oregon State University. Over 25,000 people filled Reser Stadium where Dr. Kiessling highlighted the importance for graduates in all fields to stay involved with government throughout their lives to help our democracy, and to help shape the course of science and society. Dr. Kiessling was presented with an Honorary Doctorate, and even took on the rival ducks! (See the video on our site!)

Lifetime Achievement

In March, Dr. Kiessling received a Lifetime Achievement Award at the 2014 HIV Congress held in Mumbia, India. This award recognizes her work on understanding HIV infection, establishment of the SPAR program, and her current work with HIV

A Track Record Of Translating Basic Research To Patient Care

In 1996, the Bedford Research Foundation was formed in response to a need for specialized tests and services that were not available anywhere in the world. Today, we still provide these specialized tests and it has led us to a new model of funding:

“The Foundation is a forward thinking institution that covers overhead costs by fee-for-service testing, thus allowing philanthropic donations to go directly to research.”
– Alan Geismer, Chairman,
Board of Trustees

Our work to derive a human stem cell line that is resistant to HIV infection (Engineered to “knock-out” the HIV receptor. See the video on our site!) cannot be federally funded because of an amendment restricting the budget of the National Institutes of Health. This research is, therefore, entirely dependent upon philanthropy.

In addition to basic science, our team is also focused on moving stem cell research from “bench to bedside.” Capital is needed to equip an FDA-approved laboratory module in our new location. Please consider donating today, every gift makes a difference.

Who is Bedford Research Foundation?

 

Donate Today

“Bedford’s stem cell work this year has moved the field closer to the realization of a curative therapy for HIV.”
– Dr. David Digiusto
Director of the Laboratory for Cellular Medicine at City of Hope & Bedford Research Science Advisory Committee Member Since 2013

Each Experiment Brings Us Closer

The average foundation laboratory experiment costs $90,000. Because most of our overhead is covered by fee-for-service laboratory tests, every dollar you donate goes directly toward these experiments. This innovative funding model allows Bedford Research scientists greater flexibility to move the work quickly in promising new directions. Progress requires meeting our annual funding goals. Please become a supporter and help us do more experiments this year.

Donate Today!

Cytomegalovirus (CMV) is More Common in Semen Than Generally Thought, According to a New Study

Cytomegalovirus (CMV) is more common in semen than generally thought, according to a new study by Bedford Research Foundation scientists.

CMV is a common herpes virus that causes a minor disease in children and adults, but can also infect fetuses in utero and causes permanent problems in 1 out of 750 children born in the U.S.

In the February issue of Fertility and Sterility, the official journal of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM), Bedford Research scientists report two surprising findings: First, nearly half (45%) of the semen specimens from 68 men without and with HIV co-infection had detectable CMV, including specimens from two men who initially tested negative for antibody against CMV in their blood. Second, men with even mild suppression of their immune system were twice as likely (57%) to have CMV in their semen as men with normal immunity (28%).

Read More

Bedford Research Foundation 2013 Newsletter

Read about all of the progress and the research that has occurred at the Foundation over the course of the past year! Dr. Kiessling outlines her vision for the upcoming year as well. Thank you for your support.


“Off-the-shelf” Engineered Stem Cells: Are They Therapeutically Valuable?

The astounding 2013 report by an Oregon research team of the successful creation of stem cells from a somatic cell nucleus transferred into an unfertilized human egg was met with surprising calm by the lay press and the bioethics community. This is in sharp contrast to the outcry a decade ago when similar experiments were denounced as “human cloning” and the U.S. congress rumbled with attempts to outlaw all such research with human eggs. Public concern was further fueled by an extraordinary scientific fraud in 2005 by a South Korean research team that falsely claimed to have created such stem cells.

The 2013 calm is a clear, positive sign that the newness — and the shock — of the promise of stem cell regenerative medicine has worn off. Thousands of young scientists have been trained since the 1999 cover of Science announced stem cells as the “breakthrough of the year.”

So where are the stem cell therapies? Where are the cures for diabetes, spinal cord injuries/diseases, stroke, HIV/AIDS, Parkinson’s disease, heart and kidney failure? Are they coming?

The answer is yes. But painfully slowly for the patients and families in need. Why?

Because new therapies involve both new scientific discoveries and additional tests for medical safety. Demonstrating that stem cells can turn into heart muscle or nerve cells in a petri dish is exciting, but very far from therapeutic use.

One big stumbling block is the source of the stem cells to be used for therapies.Must they be patient-specific? Or could a bank of fully characterized, “off-the-shelf”stem cells be created? Stem cells that could be administered immediately in the emergency room when the heart attack,stroke or spinal cord injury occurs?Perhaps while patient-specific stem cells were being created

According to estimates, only a few hundred stem cell lines could tissue match more than 95% of the world’s population.

This is an exciting prospect and an achievable goal. The stem cells could even be genetically engineered if needed to treat specific conditions, such as HIV/AIDS.

Bedford Research Foundation scientists are pursuing a promising example of engineering stem cells — to have a resistance to HIV infection. The work follows a proof-of-principle report by a German medical team in 2009. Because HIV infects the immune system, it is theoretically treatable by bone marrow stem cell transplant. But past attempts have shown transplanted bone marrow becomes HIV infected, making it an unsuitable treatment approach for HIV disease. This changed when the bone marrow transplant in Germany resulted in an apparent cure of the patient’s HIV disease — because the transplanted bone marrow stem cells were naturally deficient in CCR5, an receptor on the surface of cells important for HIV infection.

Without the receptor, cells are resistant to HIV infection.

Now the task at hand is to create stem cells missing CCR5 that are tissue matched to the HIV infected person. Deleting CCR5 in patient-specific (e.g. nuclear transplant, induced pluripotency, testis or parthenote) stem cells might work. “Off-the-shelf”, engineered stem cells might also work if they tissue match the patient. Our 2013 Activated Egg Symposium brings together pioneers in genetic engineering (Mario Cappeccchi and Rudolf Jaenisch) with stem cell specialists (Treena Arinzeh, Gordon Carmichael, Kim Tremblay, Jose Cibelli, David DiGiusto) and a member of the Oregon SCNT team, David Battaglia, to present their work and perspectives in research areas important to move the work forward as fast as safely possible to patient therapies. Bedford Research scientists are positioned to move faster than some traditional academic laboratories because we are not dependent upon federal funds. The parthenote research, highly promising for modifying stem cell genes, cannot be funded by the NIH because of long-time federal funding restrictions. Much of our laboratory overhead is funded through fee for service laboratory testing, allowing research donations to go directly to research. We are accountable to individual donors to return the maximum value for every dollar given to the research. Private donations — of all sizes — are essential to achieving the research speed needed by patients.

Thank you for your support.

With gratitude,

Ann A Kiessling, PhD

BSCRF Scientists Discover Developmental Differences Between Mouse Embryos and Parthenotes

Figure 2: Histogram of timing of cell cleavages following fertilization (top) or parthenogenetic activation (bottom). Wavy background line is temperature (right axis).

The current goal of BSCRF research is to optimize the efficiency of deriving pluripotent stem cells from testis and unfertilized human eggs (parthenotes) for patient specific and perhaps stem cell bank use.

In 2009, Bedford Research scientists discovered that circadian rhythm genes are“on” in early human embryos, suggesting circadian signals may be important to stem cell derivation and stability. If true, new methods of culturing stem cells in laboratories that mimic circadian signals need to be developed.

In the body, the rhythm of circadian genesis supported by several types of signals,including light/dark cycles, hormone pulses, body temperature variations, and eating. The signals regulate the pattern of circadian genes turning “on” and “off” in 24 hour cycles. In contrast, to date, stem cells have been cultured in constant temperature in the dark, their only potential circadian signal being renewal of their culture medium.

To begin to understand the importance of circadian temperature oscillations to stem cell derivation and expansion, BSCRF scientists have taken advantage of their newly developed “circadian incubator time lapse video microscope” to chronicle the first five days of development of mouse embryos and parthenotes, which are being used as models because cell division is easy to see in a group of mouse embryos/parthenotes. The goal is to discover if temperature oscillations play an important role in stem cell derivation or differentiation into useful cell types, such as neurons or bone marrow stem cells.The work is ongoing.

As shown in Figure 2, results to date indicate the first cleavage of a mouse egg to two-cells takes place at approximately the same time after fertilization or parthenogenic activation, the second cleavage to 3 cells and 4 cells is markedly delayed in the parthenotes, the intervals to the third cleavages (5 to 8 cells) are approximately the same, but development to blastocyst is again delayed in the parthenotes. This indicates the parthenotes need additional developmental support at the 2-cell stage and at the 8- to 16-cell stage. Discovering the needed support, and its relationship to circadian signals, may markedly improve testis and parthenote stem cell derivation, and speed up the project to derive genetically modified parthenote stem cells.

Progress In Testis Stem Cells

Thanks to generous donations, BSCRF scientists are in Phase III of the human testis stem cell project.

That the adult human testis contains pluripotent stem cells, in addition to sperm stem cells, was a surprising report by two research teams a few years ago. Thanks to private donations, Bedford Research scientists are determining the efficiency with which this naturally occurring source of pluripotent cells can be isolated and expanded into therapeutically useful,patient-specific stem cells. They have adopted Good Laboratory Practices for the testis stem cell derivation to shorten the time to FDA approval of derived lines.

Phase III is a collaboration with Dr. Martin Dym, Georgetown University, who has generously provided cryopreserved biopsies of the testis tissues their lab used.One of the challenges with testis stem  is distinguishing pluripotent stem cells (about 500 per gram of tissue) from the sperm stem cells (about 5 million per gram of tissue) that actively divide to produce many millions of sperm daily –the proverbial needle in a haystack. If the cell dynamics are similar to bone marrow,the pluripotent stem cell is quiescent until activated, in contrast to the sperm stem cell that is actively renewing. Current experiments in the Bedford lab are taking advantage of this difference to help isolate the stem cells

At The ISSCR

Dr. Kiessling (left) answers questions during a poster session at the meeting.

In June, 2013, BSCRF presented a poster and hosted a booth at the 11th Annual International Society for Stem Cell Research meeting. The poster titled,“Onset of Period 2 Oscillation Coincides with Differentiation of Mouse Embryonic Stem Cells” was selected from a record number of abstracts submitted. It reported the conclusion that the important circadian gene, Period 2, is turned on in stem cells,but begins to oscillate throughout the colony when the stem cells begin to differentiate. Although the importance of circadian rhythms to organ function is growing in recognition, the Foundation’s report was one of only two on circadian rhythms at the ISSCR.

New Staff

Alexis Agnew joins the team as our SPAR coordinator,bringing over ten years of medical experience in both private practice and the US Air Force. SPAR is instrumental in helping couples living with HIV disease safely parent.

 

Valia Dinopoulou, a one-year fellow, hails from the laboratory of Dr. Dimitrius Loutradis, Professor and Chairman of Obstetrics,Gynecology and Reproductive Biology, University of Athens, Greece. Valia will work on the project to genetically engineer parthenote stem cells.

Who is Bedford Research Foundation?

Philanthropy Is The Key To Continued Progress

The average cost of each experiment is $90,000. Because much of our overhead is covered by fee-for-service laboratory tests, 92% of every dollar donated goes directly toward these experiments. This innovative funding model allows Bedford Research scientists greater flexibility to move quickly in promising new research directions.

Continued progress requires meeting our annual funding goal of $450,000 in 2019.

Donate Today!

Human Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer For Patient Specific Stem Cells: Will It Work?

What is Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer (SCNT)?

SCNT is a phrase coined by scientists to describe the process of injecting the nucleus (which contains the chromosomes) from another cell in the body into a human egg. Last week a team of Oregon scientists reported creating four unique stem cells by this process (Cell, June, 2013 (pdf)). This work is a follow-up to studies originally reported by Bedford Research Foundation scientists, Jose Cibelli and Ann Kiessling, in 2001 (Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer in Humans: Pronuclear and Early Embryonic Development. J of Regenerative Medicine (pdf)).

Why are the new stem cells important?

Stem cell-based treatments, termed regenerative medicine, are being developed to replace defective tissues and organs such as heart and kidney failure, spinal cord injury and disease, diabetes, AIDS, Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s diseases, and degenerative joints. The source of the stem cells is key. If they can be harvested from the patient, there will be no problems with tissue rejection, such as can happen with kidney or heart or bone marrow transplants from donors. SCNT provides a powerful method to create stem cells with the patient’s own chromosomes, thus a perfect tissue match. SCNT had been accomplished in many species, but not human.

human egg blue dnaThe human egg is a huge cell, that is released from the ovary surrounded by cells that support it. The blue areas shown above are the DNA, the genetic information contained within each cell. The cluster of blue within the egg is the egg’s chromosomes, half of which will be expelled when the sperm enters, so the developing embryo will have genetic information from both the mother and the father.For parthenogenesis, the egg chromosomes alone guide development, for SCNT, the chromosomes are usually removed with a tiny pipette so the only genetic information remaining is from the transferred nucleus.

Background to SCNT

SCNT was first performed several decades ago to test whether or not every cell in the body contains all the genetic information of the individual. For example, does a liver cell contain all the genetic information to form every other type of cell, but “non-liver” genes are silenced? Or does a liver cell lose other genes and only retain “liver” genes?

Dr. John Gordon received the Nobel Prize in 2012 for demonstrating in 1958 that tadpole cell nuclei contained all the chromosomes necessary to form new frogs following transfer into frog eggs whose own chromosomes had been removed. The new frogs were genetically identical to the tadpole. Frogs were the first cloned animals.

For nearly three decades, it was believed that although successful with amphibia, mammals could not be cloned by transferring a nucleus into an egg, although other types of studies had confirmed that all cells contain all the genetic information needed to form a new being.

In 1997, to the surprise of the scientific community, Dolly the sheep was cloned by SCNT into a sheep egg, thus proving that like frogs, mammals could also be cloned from a single cell (Ian Wilmut at the Activated Egg Symposium (video)). Since then, many species have been similarly cloned, including mice, rats, rabbits, dogs, goats and cattle.

What is the magic contained within an egg?

Perhaps partly because of its enormous size, an egg has a unique capacity to remodel the structure of chromosomes, including its own and those of sperm. The remodeling allows expression of all the genetic information needed for stem cell pluripotency. Without being fertilized by sperm, eggs can be activated to generate stem cells, parthenote stem cells (1 min video about Parthenotes), using their own chromosomes. Parthenote stem cells have all the pluripotency characteristics of stem cells derived from human embryos (1 min video about hES). These studies suggested that SCNT would be highly successful in human eggs.

Why no human SCNT cells before now?

The inability to derive a line of stem cells from SCNT into human eggs has been a mystery, thought to be related to the status of the egg itself.

Thirteen years ago, Bedford Research scientists (JRM, 2001 (pdf)) reported side by side experiments activating human eggs parthenogenetically and by SCNT. Although 12 out of 22 parthenote eggs did divide and progress to the blastocyst stage, only 3 out of 19 SCNT eggs divided once or twice, and none progressed to the blastocyst stage (schematic). These results led to the current ongoing work by Bedford Research scientists to fully characterize gene expression in normal 8-Cell human embryos to begin to understand the problems with human parthenotes and SCNT eggs (JARG 2010JARG 2009).

eight cell human embryo
8-cell human embryo

A few years later, a large South Korean scientific team, well experienced in SCNT and animal cloning, reported the successful generation of several stem cell lines from SCNT into human eggs. The reports were quickly dispelled by other South Korean scientists as being totally fraudulent. This was a huge blow to the integrity of the stem cell scientific community.

Nonetheless, the lesson learned from the South Korean reports is that they had access to approximately 2,000 human eggs and had been unsuccessful in SCNT. This revealed loud and clear that there was a fundamental difference between human eggs and those of other mammals.

Two years ago, a New York scientific team headed up by Dieter Egli (AES 2011Time 2011) reported deriving SCNT stem cells from human eggs whose chromosomes had not been removed (Nature, Vol 478). There was something helpful about leaving the human egg chromosomes in the egg during the activation process. This is regarded as an important breakthrough even though the resulting stem cells contain twice as many chromosomes as normal stem cells.

And now comes the Oregon scientific team reporting the successful derivation of SCNT stem cell lines by utilizing advances in egg culture, activation, and chromosome removal. Nonetheless, that unknown egg-specific factors play a role, however, was shown by marked differences in SCNT success rates.

Unfortunately, there are irregularities in the manuscript reported in Cell (Science Magazine, May 23, 2013), thus once again casting a shadow over the work. Other scientific teams are currently investigating the cell lines to determine the accuracy of the report.

Are SCNT eggs actually embryos?

Accuracy of language for new technologies involving human eggs will provide the balanced framework necessary for everyone to evaluate the value — and the threat — of SCNT technology (CT law review). If “embryo” is reserved for the unique union of egg and sperm, and if other activities of human eggs have more accurate terms, such as parthenote for eggs activated with their own chromosomes, and SCNT-egg (or “ovasome”) for eggs activated following SCNT, there will be far less confusion, especially by the non-scientific community.

Whether or not SCNT-eggs should be assigned the same status as embryos since there is the potential — however small — that such an entity could develop further if transferred into a uterus (“human cloning”) is a separate consideration from whether or not they should be termed “embryos.” New technologies need new terms.